Based on coverage from CBC, Sudbury.com, and Terrace Standard.
BC Hydro is embroiled in a legal battle with a family of ranchers in Vanderhoof, B.C., over access to land critical for the construction of the North Coast Transmission Line (NCTL). This $6-billion project, designated as "nation-building" by the federal government, aims to power new gas and mining ventures in northern B.C.'s "golden triangle."
BC Hydro's Legal Action Against Ranchers
The Crown utility has filed a petition in B.C. Supreme Court against Kenneth and Carolyn Fawcett, owners of Little Valley Farms, a multi-generational beef operation. BC Hydro alleges the family has wrongfully blocked access to properties under rights-of-way, preventing necessary pre-construction activities like forestry, archaeological, and environmental surveys. The utility claims these delays could lead to increased costs and broader economic impacts, including potential rate hikes for customers.
Ongoing Dispute and Allegations
The conflict has been simmering since 2023, with BC Hydro and the Fawcetts unable to reach an agreement despite ongoing discussions. Court documents reveal the family's concerns over property damage, including crop destruction and livestock incidents, allegedly caused by BC Hydro's activities. An email from a property contractor claims Kenneth Fawcett accused BC Hydro of "squatting" on his land, suggesting tensions have escalated.
Potential Impact on Project Timeline
BC Hydro warns that continued obstruction could delay the NCTL's first phase, scheduled to begin next summer and become operational by 2030. The utility argues that any postponement might lead to substantial additional costs and hinder new projects dependent on the transmission line. Moreover, without the NCTL, existing projects may continue using gas and diesel, increasing greenhouse gas emissions.
Seeking Court Intervention
In response to the impasse, BC Hydro is seeking a court order to authorize the RCMP to enforce access to the properties. The utility emphasizes that it has reached agreements with other landowners along the route, highlighting the Fawcetts' case as an outlier. The petition, however, remains untested in court, and the Fawcetts have yet to file a response.
Broader Implications for BC Hydro and Residents
The outcome of this legal battle could have significant ramifications for BC Hydro and its customers. Delays in the NCTL project might not only inflate costs but also stall economic development in northern B.C. The utility's petition underscores the project's importance to the province's hydro infrastructure, framing it as essential for future energy needs.
As the case unfolds, the stakes remain high for both BC Hydro and the Fawcett family, with potential impacts on the broader community and the environment.
Source 1 | Source 2 | Source 3
Multiple outlets covered this story. The coverage was largely consistent across CBC, Sudbury.com, and Terrace Standard, all reporting on BC Hydro's legal actions against the Fawcett family for allegedly blocking access to land needed for the North Coast Transmission Line. However, the Terrace Standard uniquely highlighted the project's significance in powering new gas and mining projects in the "golden triangle" region, which was not mentioned by the other sources. Additionally, Sudbury.com included a detail about Prime Minister Mark Carney's involvement, noting his announcement of the project as "nation-building," providing a broader political context to the story.
